Whilst it is the anniversary this year of the end of steam on BR, in 1968, just 20 years earlier, a series of comparative trials took place across the country, to analyses what was then the best in steam traction design, construction and operation. Not surprisingly, these trials – which took place between April and August 1948, were latched on to by enthusiasts – as a form of competition to see which railway had the best steam types.

A classic shot of a classic pacific – although 46236 “City of Bradford” was used in the 1948 trials. Seen here is sister loco 46242 “City of Glasgow” on the inaugural run of The Caledonian in June 1957. Photo: RPB Collection

‘A4’ Class No. 60004 “William Whitelaw” at York on an enthusiasts’ special in the 1960s. As an express passenger type, it was natural to choose one of Gresley’s A4s, but 60022 “Mallard” did not acquit herself well, and was substituted by 60033/34 for the Interchanges. Photo Courtesy: Lens of Sutton
70 years ago, a series of trials took place on the newly nationalised British railway network, to contrast and compare the best elements of the locomotive engineering design, and practice used by railways across Britain. Well, at least that was the plan.
The trials led, eventually to the new BR Standard steam locomotives, and covered espress passenger, mixed traffic and freight types, including a selection of some of the latest designs, WD ‘Austerity’ types, and some traditional designs. The process was not particularly controversial, but new steam locomotives in the 1950s – especially as diesel and electric traction had already been established, and was developing rapidly.

The LMS built this 2-8-0 in huge numbers – with over 600 in service by 1948. Many having been built by the other main line railway companies, Beyer Peacock and North British Loco. for war service at home and overseas. A natural choice perhaps for the 1948 trials. Photo: RPB Collection
It may be that one of the main drivers was the ease of availability of coal as a fuel,where oil had to be imported, and the cost of electric traction’s infrastructure was expensive in the post-war economy of the UK.
Further reading
Clicking on the image below will take you to a more detailed discussion of the trials:
Useful Links:
National Archive – Report of the Locomotive Testing Committee
RM Web – The 1948 Locomotive Exchange Trials – Discussions
1948 Locomotive Exchange Trials
I am wcontacting you because there is a link on this page of your website
https://twsmedia.co.uk/2018/07/13/british-railways-interchange-trials-1948/
to what was the Southern E-mail Group’s website. Please note that the name has
now changed to Southern Railway E-mail Group (SREmG) and the website address to:
https://sremg.org.uk
The link in question is now: https://sremg.org.uk/RlyMag/LocoInterchangeTrials1948.pdf
Thank you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hello Peter – very many thanks for comment, I’ve updated the link with the details you sent. It’s always nice to receive comments and help from anyone who’s read my occasional scribblings. Many thanks again. Rodger
LikeLike